My dog loves the peanut butter treat. We've been using apple and pumpkin for some time but the peanut butter is his favorite. Great treat to help with relaxation. He has a treat before bed nightly and sometimes during the day if stormy weather is present. I believe this and the CBD oil have helped with his cancer since chemo is no longer an option. 3 year survivor and I am so happy! A definite fan of CBD use for everyone including the fur babies.